Remedies for Disclosure Violations Under California Law
When sellers, agents, or brokers fail to disclose known defects or material facts about a property, buyers in California have several legal remedies available to protect their rights and recover losses. California law provides mechanisms for addressing financial, legal, and contractual harms caused by disclosure violations. Below, we outline the primary remedies available to buyers under California law.
1. Rescission of the Sale
Buyers may be entitled to rescind (cancel) the sale agreement when the failure to disclose a material issue has significantly impacted the value or desirability of the property. Rescission effectively unwinds the transaction, restoring the buyer and seller to their pre-contract positions.
Relevant Law:
- California Civil Code Section 1689 allows rescission of contracts where consent was obtained through fraud, undue influence, or material misrepresentation.
2. Monetary Damages
Buyers can seek financial compensation for losses resulting from the failure to disclose. Damages may include:
- Repair and Remediation Costs: Compensation for repairing undisclosed defects such as structural damage, mold, pest infestations, or non-permitted work.
- Diminished Property Value: If the undisclosed issue permanently reduces the property’s value, buyers can seek damages for the difference between the property’s purchase price and its actual value.
Relevant Law:
- California Civil Code Section 3343 specifies the measure of damages in cases of fraud, including out-of-pocket losses and, in some cases, additional consequential damages.
3. Retroactive Appraisal Remedies
California law recognizes that undisclosed material defects may require a retroactive appraisal to determine the true value of the property at the time of purchase. Buyers can recover the difference between the purchase price and the appraised value, accounting for the undisclosed issues.
Relevant Law:
- California Civil Code Section 3343 permits buyers to recover damages based on the loss of market value due to fraudulent nondisclosure.
4. Punitive Damages for Fraud
In cases where the seller, agent, or broker acted with intentional fraud, buyers may seek punitive damages. These damages are intended to punish egregious behavior and deter similar misconduct in the future.
Relevant Law:
- California Civil Code Section 3294 outlines the conditions under which punitive damages may be awarded, requiring evidence of malice, oppression, or fraud.
5. Specific Performance
In some cases, buyers may seek specific performance, requiring the seller to fulfill their contractual obligations. This remedy is most often used when monetary damages are insufficient, such as when the buyer has a unique interest in the property.
Relevant Law:
- California Civil Code Section 3384 permits specific performance when monetary damages cannot adequately compensate for a breach of contract.
6. Attorney’s Fees and Costs
California law allows buyers to recover attorney’s fees and litigation costs if such provisions are included in the purchase agreement or are awarded under specific statutes.
Relevant Law:
- California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1032 provides for the recovery of litigation costs, and attorney’s fees may be awarded under applicable contract terms or statutes.
7. Additional Remedies Through Mediation or Arbitration
Many California real estate purchase agreements include mediation and arbitration clauses. While these processes can provide quicker resolutions, buyers should consult an attorney to ensure their rights are fully protected during these proceedings. Mediation can help negotiate repair costs or damages, while arbitration may lead to a binding decision.
Relevant Law:
California Civil Code Section 1281 governs the enforceability of arbitration agreements.
How Bay Legal, PC Can Help
At Bay Legal, PC, we specialize in navigating the complex remedies available to buyers affected by disclosure violations. Our attorneys will:
- Assess your case to determine the most appropriate remedy under California law
- Advocate for your rights during mediation, arbitration, or litigation
- Work with appraisers, inspectors, and other experts to establish the extent of your damages
Contact Us
If you believe you have been harmed by undisclosed issues in a real estate transaction, contact Bay Legal, PC today. We will guide you through your legal options and help you achieve a fair resolution.
Contact Bay Legal